Sign up to save tools and stay up to date with the latest in AI
bg
bg
1

Ask HN: Songwriters, what software do you use?

Jan 22, 2025 - news.ycombinator.com
The article is a discussion among songwriters about the software and tools they use for songwriting. Participants mention a variety of tools, including Logic Pro, Dorico, Rhymezone, and traditional methods like paper and pen. Some express skepticism about AI-assisted songwriting tools, viewing them as potentially diminishing the creative process, while others find AI tools useful for specific tasks like mastering or generating ideas. There is a general preference for tools that assist rather than replace the creative process, with some songwriters emphasizing the importance of maintaining a personal touch in their work.

Additionally, the discussion touches on the use of AI in music creation, with differing opinions on its value and originality. Some participants argue that AI lacks the human experience necessary for true artistic expression, while others see it as a tool that can aid in specific aspects of songwriting. The conversation also includes mentions of specific software features and personal workflows, highlighting the diverse approaches songwriters take in their creative processes.

Key takeaways:

  • Many songwriters prefer traditional tools like paper, pen, and voice memos over digital solutions for capturing ideas quickly and maintaining focus.
  • AI-assisted tools are viewed with skepticism by some songwriters, who feel they may detract from the creative process or result in less authentic work.
  • Some songwriters use AI and digital tools selectively, such as for brainstorming, proof-reading, or generating musical ideas, but often replace AI-generated content with human-created tracks.
  • There is interest in developing or finding software that combines text and audio features to better support the songwriting process, including tracking alternative lyrics and syncing with music notation.
View Full Article

Comments (0)

Be the first to comment!