Sign up to save tools and stay up to date with the latest in AI
bg
bg
1

Bryan Cantrill on AI Doomerism: Intelligence Is Not Enough

Dec 10, 2023 - thenewstack.io
Bryan Cantrill, co-founder and CTO of Oxide Computer Company, has dismissed fears that artificial intelligence (AI) could wipe out humanity as overblown and unsubstantiated. Speaking at the 11th annual Monktoberfest, Cantrill argued that the idea of AI developing a bioweapon or novel molecular nanotechnology was laughable and that the real risks posed by AI were its potential to exacerbate existing societal problems such as racism and economic dislocation. He also noted that AI lacks crucial human attributes such as willpower, desire, and drive, and cannot engineer autonomously.

Cantrill further criticized the idea of pausing all AI research as "brazenly authoritarian" and potentially leading to violent scenarios. He suggested that those fearing AI should focus on enforcing existing regulations around potentially dangerous technologies. Cantrill concluded by stating that the real-world problems that AI could exacerbate should be the focus, rather than hypothetical scenarios of AI-induced human extinction.

Key takeaways:

  • Bryan Cantrill, co-founder and CTO of Oxide Computer Company, dismisses the fear that AI could extinguish humanity as wildly unsubstantiated and even laughable.
  • Cantrill argues that pausing all AI development would be "brazenly authoritarian" and could lead to scary scenarios, including the justification of violence to protect humanity.
  • He emphasizes that intelligence alone does not solve problems, and that human attributes such as resilience, teamwork, and optimism are crucial in engineering and problem-solving.
  • While Cantrill sees the risk of human extinction as too small to worry about, he acknowledges that AI can act as a force multiplier on existing problems such as racism and economic dislocation, and that AI ethics is exceedingly important.
View Full Article

Comments (0)

Be the first to comment!