The court has refused to grant an interim injunction in ANI’s favour and has scheduled the next hearing for 28 January 2025. The outcome of the case could set a precedent for stricter rules on using copyrighted content for training AI models and may also determine if Indian copyright law considers AI-generated outputs as derivative works. The case is expected to address several critical questions surrounding copyright and AI, including whether scraping and using copyrighted content without authorization for training AI models constitutes copyright infringement, and whether such use can be considered “fair dealing" under India’s Copyright Act.
Key takeaways:
- ANI, a news agency in India, has filed a lawsuit against OpenAI for alleged copyright infringement, marking the first legal challenge to generative AI models in the country.
- OpenAI has denied any wrongdoing, arguing that copyright laws protect the expression of ideas, not facts or ideas themselves, and that its servers are located outside India, making the lawsuit jurisdictionally irrelevant.
- The Delhi High Court has refused to grant an interim injunction in ANI’s favour, acknowledging the case’s complexity and the need for detailed deliberations. The outcome of this case could establish a legal framework for regulating AI content in India.
- The case is expected to address several critical questions surrounding copyright and AI, including whether scraping and using copyrighted content without authorization for training AI models constitutes copyright infringement, and whether such use can be considered “fair dealing" under India’s Copyright Act.