Sign up to save tools and stay up to date with the latest in AI
bg
bg
1

NY Lawmaker Uses AI to Write Housing Bill That Does Little to Help Renters

Jul 14, 2023 - gizmodo.com
A New York legislator, Assemblyman Clyde Vanel, used artificial intelligence (AI) to research and draft a bill requiring landlords to provide renters a copy of their lease agreement upon request. The bill, which was largely ineffective and did not address major issues faced by renters, was part of an experiment conducted by Vanel's office using Auto-GPT, an AI "agent". Despite the bill's shortcomings, Vanel's office believed the AI had identified an issue that others had not considered.

However, the article argues that AI is not effective at determining benefits for humanity or interpreting data, but rather is derivative. It cites examples of AI-based "lawyers" being quashed by courts and lawyers being fined for using AI to write legal documents. The article also highlights the ongoing housing crisis in New York, with skyrocketing rent prices and landlords hiding behind LLCs, issues which the AI-drafted bill did not address.

Key takeaways:

  • A New York legislator, Assemblyman Clyde Vanel, used AI to research and draft a piece of legislation, Bill 6896, which would require landlords to provide renters a copy of their lease agreement upon request.
  • The bill was researched and written by artificial intelligence, with the accuracy and language reviewed and refined by humans. The AI used was Auto-GPT, a kind of AI “agent.”
  • However, the bill does not address key issues that rental advocacy groups are concerned about, and it does not mention anything about enforcement, so any compliance would depend on the generosity of the landlord themselves.
  • The article argues that AI is not effective at determining the benefits for humanity and that it is not interpretive, but derivative. This is why AI-based “lawyers” like DoNotPay’s model was quashed by the courts.
View Full Article

Comments (0)

Be the first to comment!