The 'Worst in Show' CES products put your data at risk and cause waste, privacy advocates say
Jan 09, 2025 - financialpost.com
At the CES event, a panel of experts identified several products as "Worst in Show" due to concerns over privacy, sustainability, and repairability. The Ultrahuman Rare Luxury Smart Ring was criticized for being "least repairable" because its battery cannot be replaced without destroying the device. Bosch's AI-powered crib, which collects extensive data on infants, was highlighted for privacy concerns. SoundHound AI's In-Car Commerce Ecosystem was deemed "least sustainable" for promoting wasteful consumption, while TP-Link's Archer BE900 router was flagged for security vulnerabilities. Samsung's AI Washing Machine and LG's AI Home Inside 2.0 Refrigerator were also criticized for unnecessary features that increase costs and reduce product lifespan.
The panel emphasized that while technology can enhance lives, it often comes with trade-offs in privacy, security, and environmental impact. Products like the AI crib and smart appliances were seen as exploiting consumer fears and desires for convenience, leading to excessive data collection and increased waste. The experts called for more sustainable and privacy-conscious innovations, highlighting the need for better repairability and longer product lifespans to reduce environmental harm.
Key takeaways:
The CES 'Worst in Show' awards highlight products that pose risks to privacy, sustainability, and repairability.
The Ultrahuman Rare Luxury Smart Ring was criticized for being "least repairable" due to its non-replaceable battery.
Bosch's AI-powered smart crib was noted for excessive data collection, raising privacy concerns for parents.
TP-Link's Archer BE900 router was deemed "least secure" due to vulnerabilities and compliance with Chinese law on security flaw reporting.
